TRO / Schedule A 案件

26-cv-569

案件基础信息

案件号
26-cv-569
立案日期
2026-04-06
原告品牌
Lily & Val
原告律所
Keith
起诉州
PA
侵权类型
版权

案件进程

编号日期案件进程
242026-06-07UNREDACTED COMPLAINT against TINNERS TOME, ABL SIGN, ADAS LOVE, AEGISCREW, AFMAISONUE, AI XUE, AL ART SHOP, ALABIL, ALL CERAMIC VASES, AMOBO, ANTIEPIHUA, AODAIFEN SHOP, ART AND CRAFT PAINTING, ART OF DECORATIVE, ARTFUL LIVIN WALL WONDERS AESTHETIC HAVEN, ARTISTRY HAVEN CREATIONS, ARTISTRYHIVE, ARTVOYAGE CREATIONS, AURORA AAA, AURORA ART SHOP, AWGN, BAEKTAM BOOK ART, BAGSTYLE SHOP, BEAUTIFUL RETRO IRON PAINTING, BELOVED ART SHOP, BETTYSSHOP, BIG FAT RICH, BKBW, BKQGE, BMZJ LL, BOAO ART, BOGOLK, BRAVE ART PAINTING, BRUSHSTROKE BOUTIQUE A, BYGONE BEAUTIES, C DISTANT DECORATIVE PAINTING, CACKLECOVE, CAI CR, CAIJINGNNNN, CAMELK, CANVAS NOOK, CANVAS PAINTING REPLACEMENT CORE BOUTIQUE, CHARMING A GIFT, CHCHAO SIGNS, CHEN JIAN MING TIN, ChenCanvasPainting, CHICTEEHUB, CHUANGJIE ACRYLIC DECORATION LOCAL, CHUN LIN, CITYSTYLE, CLASSIC COUTURE COLLECTION, CLASSICWAVE, CLOTHCANVAS, CNNGUX SHOP, CONTEXTURE ART CSS, COOL MEN HALL, COSY EMPORIUM, COZYCORNERDECOR B, CQY HAD, CQYIXIN, CUSTOMTIN SIGNS, CX ART SHOP, CY SIGN, CYAUREL, CYCLING SPORT SHOP, CZAI K, D AIO DECORATIVE PAINTING, D DISTANT DECORATIVE PAINTING, DAILY DEALS A, DAYAFTERDAY, DDL PAINTING, DECEMBER WINTER LEAVES, DecoMuse, DECORATIO N, DECORATIVE DIAGRAM G, DECORATIVE SIGN AAA, DIYTINSIGNSHOPS, DIYVA, DOULINK, DPDB, DRAPEE, DRAPEY, DYSEO PROBEGUE, E HIGH DECORATIVE PAINTING, ELEGANCE CHOICE, ELEGANCECORNER, ENCOUNTERING YOU ART, ENDLESSPERSONAL, ERAKSJN, EXPAND IMAGINATION, EXPAND IMAGINATION LOCAL, FF ONES, FFAINELW, FFGQOVFQP, FFQGQIQ, FG ART SHOP, FIZZ ART, FJWOZUQV, FLASH DESIGN, FLIPFLUFF, FLORA ONE, FORGED FRAMES, FOURBEAR OIL, FRAME PAINTING DECORATION, FREEDOM CENTER, FTPKWJIT, FTRWBHUG, FUNNY AND INTERESTING, FURNITURE FOR DISPLAY SIGN, FWJYUVCR, FWTIYLNI, FZKJ SHOP, G SUPER DECORATIVE PAINTING, GALERA DE ORO, GHJRTYRTT, GIFTWOVN, GLO VALUE CORNER, GOGO DECORATIVE PAINTING, GOOD LUCK TO FOLLOW, GOOD PERSIMMONS A, GORGEOUSGOODS, GRAPHICS TABLET, GROOVESTER, GUO COZY HAVEN, GUO RUSTIC CHARM, GUO SERENITY DCOR, HAIDIAN SHOP, HANG ZHOU ART, HANGING CANVAS PAINTING, HAPPYHOME III, HARDWARE DECORATION FACTORY LOCAL, HEMHYMN, HEMITONG, HEMITONGL, HERITAGE CANVAS PRINTS, HERITAGE SIGN STUDIO, HEXINGHAVENHOME, HHREGION, HIGH QUALITY TIN SIGNS, HKHLLJ, HKJINY DECOR, HLKTIKE SLO, HOHAPPYME, HOME DECORCM, HOUSEHOLD DECORATION KUANGHUA, HUAXIANXU, HUMBLE PUZZLE, HZTIEPIHUA, I HAPPY DECORATIVE PAINTING, IAOSGXA, ICONIC TIN WORKS, INSPIRATION COMES FROM ART, IRON ECHO STUDIO, IRON FAMILY HH, IRON PAINTING NO, IRON SHEET PAINTING MALL, IRONCANVAS, JAYTIANSIGN, JCKUBJ, JCR IZA, JERRY DECORATION, JHPEIXIN, JIBAC, JIEBK, JIULI SHAGNDIAN S, JIULI SHAGNDIAN UU, JIULI SHAGNDIAN X, JOSELYN AA, JOYPATH, JUSUNGANG, JY HOME DECORATION GALLERY, KAIDUIDGJK SHOP, KALOKALO, KJTEMUONE, KJXACBII, KJXMLBSS, KK SUPPLY, KRISLXX, KS GO, KUINDY LOCAL, LAKESIDE DECORATION LOCAL, LAND MONK, LAOOP, LAYUEWU, LCSBY, LDANTEIPIHUA SHOP, LIANZHENQING, LIBINN, LIBINQ, LILT, LIQINGFUZHAUNG LOCAL, LIU BETTER AND BETTER, LOAYJ, LOVE DIY HWC, LOVE ME LIFE, LOVE THE WALL ROOM, LOVE YOU HAPPINESS DECORATION, LOVEBLANKET CUSTOM, LSLAND TSUKIT, Lucky HomeB, LUXILUXI SHOP, LWHLWH, LX ART AND LIFE, LXS ART DECORATION, LY HOLIDAY DECORATIONS LOCAL, LZ HOME DECORS, LZMGXBBQD, M PAINTING, MARK DRAW, MESA MALL, METAL ARTISTS, METAL DECORATION HOME, METAL PLAQUE ART, METAL POSTER ART, METAL SIGN FANS, METALLICMUSE, METALLURGE DECOR, METALMARKS, METALMUSECREATIONS, METICULOUSLY CHOSEN PRODUCT, MIAO ART PAINTING B, MILLION X, MINTIEPIHUA, MP APT, MUCHMUCH, NANTAOKEJI, NEST NOOK TU, NICE FRAME PAINTING, O DISTANT DECORATIVE PAINTING, OIL PAINTER CAI, OIL PAINTING HCX B, ONEANDTWO, ONLINESTYLE, OUFULAIZHUBAOGH, OUFULAIZHUBAOKL, PAEFHWR, PAHFGB, PANDORASBOUTIQUE, PARVENU HANGINGS, PAXIMIGA, PINKPEONY, PIONEEROOO, PIXEL PULSE STUDIOS, PREMIUMPICKK, PROFESSIONAL PAINTING ART SHOP, PSDKHSFH, PTIJVB, PURETEE, Q FAST DECORATIVE PAINTING, QBHEARTHSIDE CHARMS, QEERF, QIGUOPINGA, QIGUOPINGB, QIGUOPINGE, QINQI ART, QINSDIAN, QINSHENGSHANHANG, QZTHEHEARTHQZ, RDFRDF, REGALROBE, REIGEN ARATAKA, RELIABLE FIND, RETRO METAL ARTS, RGHTLL, RHRTHBSF, RISING STAR ART GALLERY, ROGUETHREAD, S Fast decorative painting, SEREINII ART SHOP, SERENITY LE, SFDES TWO, SHANG PING YI C, SHEET METAL TREASURES, SHIRLEY WALL DECORATION, SHOOK ART STUDIO, SIGN DDF, SIGN FF, SIGNER TEB, SIGNER UEA, SIGNNEST ART LOCAL, SIYOUJIANWU, SKJRGCDGG, SMART SOURCES, SNIPIT, SONGJINGXIAOPU, SOPHIA L, SPPSRFIFTEEN, SPPSRONE, SPPSRSEVEN, SPPXPY, SQFNINE, SQFNITY, SQFTHITY, STARDRAGON FLY LIMITED, STITCHSPRK, STITCHWORKS, STYLECRAFTED SHOP, SUXIUGO, SYS ART SHOP, TEJINGHH, THE BLADE OF DOUBLE DEVIL, THE GIFTS SHOP, THE HOME OF GENUINE PRODUCTS, THE NEON VAULT, THE PAINTED VISTA, THE TIN VAULT, THREAD VERVE, THRIVING THRIFT, TIAN MALL, TIANWEIUE, TIEPI, TIME IS, TIMELESS TAILORING TREASURES, TIN PAINTING ARTS, TIN XJ, TINBRUSH STUDIO, TINMALL LOCAL, TINSPIRE, TINTAGE, TM BANANA, TM FROG, TM LOOSS, TM POSTERS, TNNEO TIN SIGN, TOGIANT LOCAL, TOP LOVE ART, TP IRON PAINTING, TP MISS, TRADEPULSEJZ, TREND LIFE, TREND RADAR, TREND VOYAGE, TREND VOYAGE C, TRENDY HAVENOK, TTP B, TYTP DECORATION, UNIQUE K LOCAL, Urban Metal Decor, URBAN METAL DECOR PRO, URBAN TEES, VERITAS HONEST LOCAL, VERSATILE CUSTOMIZATION, VERSEVILLA LOCAL, VFYIOHI, VINTAGE DECORATIVE PAINTING, VINTAGE TIN EDITIONS JIN, VISUALOV, VIVI WALL ART ONE, W STYLEHAVEN LOCAL, WALL DECOR WORLD, WALL DECORATION ZHANG, WHIMFOLK, WILD WEST THREADS, WJX ART, WOBBLELYN, WOVELY, WOVENWHIMSY, WSSQ ART, WU JIAN PING TIN, XHDDPW, XIANHUAAA, XING FEI SHOP, XKDDPW, XM ART, XMMINGYU, XXXART PRINTSII, XXXART PRINTSPP, XXXART PRINTSUU, XYW HOME DECORATION, XZXARTB, YANGDEDE, YAYABIN WALL ART, YAYAN HOUSEWEAR FURNISHINGS, YI PAINTING, YIDOM, YINEGG, YJX ART DECORATION, YOMI FINE GOODS SHOP, YOYO ART SHOP A, YU JAY ART PAINTING, YU JAY STUNNING ART GALLERY, YUJIAN ART, YUKI HOME DCOR, YYUSP, ZAVTIJ, ZBD COMING, ZCWIC, ZHANG YI XING, ZHANGLONG METAL DRAWING BOARD, ZHENGJIA CLOTH PAINTING, ZHENYUANJIAJU, ZHONGMIN TRADE, ZHUO YI HAN TIN SIGNS A, ZWINZ HAYOX, ZYH DECORATION, ZZ SUNSHINE, filed by LILY & VAL, LLC.
232026-06-04ORDER indicating that Plaintiff is directed to file the Unredacted Complaint and add all defendants to the Docket in accordance with the Schedule A instructions for filers available on the Court's website. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 6/4/2026. Text-only entry; no PDF document will issue. This text-only entry constitutes the Order of the Court or Notice on the matter.
222026-06-02NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal million X, SQFNITY, SPPXPY, JY Home Decoration Gallery, WSSQ Art, Graphics tablet, MP APT, CNNGUX shop, KaloKalo, PremiumPickk, Diyva, Trendy HavenOK, FF ONEs, PandorasBoutique, ZHANGLONG Metal drawing board, ChuangJie Acrylic Decoration local, HKJinY Dcor, Tnneo tin sign, Canvas Painting Replacement Core Boutique, JoyPath, BOGOLK, SQFTHITY, QZTheHearthQZ, QBHearthside Charms by LILY & VAL, LLC
212026-05-07ORDER DENYING 18 MOTION for Preliminary Injunction filed by Plaintiff LILY & VAL, LLC. Plaintiff initiated this action by filing a Complaint on 4/6/2026, alleging that Defendants' products are infringing on Plaintiff's copyrighted artwork. On 4/9/2026, the Court granted Plaintiff's 4 motion for a temporary restraining order, ordering the restraint of Defendants' assets and merchant storefronts, and scheduling an in-person hearing to show cause as to why preliminary injunction should not be issued to occur on 4/21/2026. One business day before the hearing, Plaintiff requested that the Court continue the hearing. ECF No. 16. The Court granted the motion, rescheduling the hearing for 5/4/2026 at 10:00 AM, in person. ECF No. 17. Plaintiff's counsel failed to appear at the hearing. Accordingly, the TRO expired according to its terms on 5/4/2026. Also on 5/4/2026, despite not appearing at the show cause hearing, Plaintiff filed a one-paragraph 18 Motion for a Preliminary Injunction with no accompanying brief. "A preliminary injunction is an extraordinary remedy never awarded as of right." Winter v. NRDC, Inc., 555 U.S. 7, 24 (2008). As the Supreme Court has recognized, the limited purpose of a preliminary injunction "is merely to preserve the relative positions of the parties until a trial on the merits can be held." Starbucks Corp. v. McKinney, 620 U.S. 339, 346 (2024) (internal citations omitted). Four factors inform a court's decision as to the issuance of a preliminary injunction: "(1) The likelihood that the plaintiff will prevail on the merits at final hearing; (2) the extent to which the plaintiff is being irreparably harmed by the conduct complained of; (3) the extent to which the defendant will suffer irreparable harm if the preliminary injunction is issued; and (4) [that] the public interest [weighs in favor of granting the injunction]." See Greater Phila. Chamber of Commerce v. City of Phila., 949 F.3d 116, 133 (3d Cir. 2020). Stated slightly differently, "any one factor may give a district court reason enough to exercise its sound discretion by denying an injunction[,]" and "[w]hen one factor is dispositive, a district court need not consider the others" to deny an injunction. Del. State Sportsman's Assoc., Inc. v. Del. Dep't of Safety & Homeland Security, 108 F.4th 194, 203 (3d Cir. 2024). Plaintiff has failed to carry its burden here. Most notably, Plaintiff has not demonstrated irreparable harm warranting renewed injunctive relief. Once Defendants were restrained under the TRO, Defendants were on notice of this action and of Plaintiff's efforts to freeze Defendants' assets. The TRO restraining Defendants' assets expired on 5/4/2026, and Plaintiff failed to appear at the hearing set to determine whether those restraints should continue. Thus, to the extent Plaintiff's irreparable-harm argument depends on the risk that Defendants will hide assets once alerted to this case, that risk has already materialized. Defendants have had notice, the restraints have lapsed, and any opportunity to move assets has already come to pass. Put differently, "the ship has sailed" on Plaintiff's request to maintain uninterrupted restraints pending resolution of this action. As the party moving for emergency relief, Plaintiff's failure to appear at the show cause hearing, or provide briefing in support of its 18 Motion for Preliminary Injunction, substantially undermines any claim that renewed emergency relief is necessary now. See Greater Phila. Chamber of Commerce, 949 F.3d at 133 (3d Cir. 2020). The remaining factors likewise do not favor issuance of preliminary injunction. The present record is limited, particularly in light of Plaintiff's failure to appear at the show cause hearing or provide briefing in support of its 18 Motion. Moreover, the balance of equities and public interest do not favor this Court's reimposition of restraints on Defendants' assets where Plaintiff has failed to appear at a hearing convened to determine whether such extraordinary relief should continue. Accordingly, Plaintiff's 18 Motion for Preliminary Injunction is DENIED. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 5/7/2026. Text-only entry; no PDF document will issue. This text-only entry constitutes the Order of the Court or Notice on the matter.
202026-05-05CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE TRO Show Cause Hearing by LILY & VAL, LLC
192026-05-04ORDER. On 4/9/2026, this Court granted Plaintiff's 4 motion for a temporary restraining order and scheduled a hearing to show cause as to why a preliminary injunction should not be issued on 4/21/2026. ECF No. 14. On Sunday, 4/19/2026, Plaintiff requested that the Court continue the hearing. ECF No. 16. The Court granted the motion the next day, rescheduling the hearing for 5/4/2026 at 10:00 AM. ECF No. 17. The Court ordered the parties to appear in person. Id. On the date and time of the hearing, Plaintiff's counsel failed to appear. The Court waited for approximately 20 minutes after the scheduled start time of the hearing, but no party appeared. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 5/4/2026. Text-only entry; no PDF document will issue. This text-only entry constitutes the Order of the Court or Notice on the matter.
182026-05-04MOTION for Preliminary Injunction by LILY & VAL, LLC.
172026-04-20ORDER GRANTING 16 Motion to Extend the Temporary Restraining Order and to Continue the Show Cause Hearing filed by Plaintiff LILY & VAL, LLC. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the Show Cause Hearing re Preliminary Injunction currently set for 4/21/2026 is RESCHEDULED to 5/4/2026 at 10:00 AM, IN PERSON in Courtroom 9B before Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Defendants' Opposition papers, if any, shall be filed on or before 4/27/2026. Plaintiff shall file any Reply papers on or before 4/30/2026. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 4/20/2026. Text-only entry; no PDF document will issue. This text-only entry constitutes the Order of the Court or Notice on the matter.
162026-04-19MOTION to Extend Time to April 29, 2026 by LILY & VAL, LLC.
152026-04-10Surety Bond BOND in the amount of $396,000 Receipt Number S-403393, posted by LILY & VAL, LLC NGM Insurance Company as Surety.
142026-04-09ORDER GRANTING 4 MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order; MOTION for Order Restraining Assets and Merchant Storefronts; MOTION for Order to Show Cause Why a Preliminary Injunction Should Not Issue; and MOTION to Expedite Discovery. Defendants are hereby ORDERED to show cause as to why a preliminary injunction should not be issued IN PERSON in Courtroom 9B on 4/21/2026 at 9:30 AM before Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand. Defendants' Opposition papers must be filed on or before 4/14/2026. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 4/9/2026.
132026-04-08Summons Issued as to SCHEDULE A DEFENDANTS
122026-04-08PRAECIPE to Issue Summons by LILY & VAL, LLC
112026-04-08SEALED DOCUMENT by LILY & VAL, LLC. This document Sealed pursuant to 10 Order on Motion for Leave to File Documents Under Seal.
102026-04-06ORDER GRANTING 5 MOTION for Leave to File Documents Under Seal filed by Plaintiff LILY & VAL, LLC. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 4/6/2026.
92026-04-06NOTICE REGARDING TELEPHONIC PROCEEDINGS: The parties are directed to use the following information to access any telephone conference scheduled in this case. Conference Phone Number: 1 412-547-0144. Phone Conference ID: 359 195 882#
82026-04-06ORDER re Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b) Motions to Dismiss as more fully stated in said order. Signed by Judge Christy Criswell Wiegand on 4/06/2026.
72026-04-06NOTICE that instant civil action has been designated for placement into the United States District Court's Alternative Dispute Resolution program. Parties are directed to fully complete the required 26(f) report, which includes the stipulation of selecting an ADR process. Counsel for plaintiff shall make service of the notice on all parties.
62026-04-06COPYRIGHT DOCUMENTS ISSUED. Emailed copy of Transmittal Letter, AO 121 Form, Complaint, Exhibits and Docket Sheet to the Register of Copyrights.
52026-04-06MOTION for Leave to File Documents Under Seal by LILY & VAL, LLC.
42026-04-06MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order, MOTION Order Restraining Assets and Merchant Storefronts, MOTION to Expedite, MOTION for Order to Show Cause by LILY & VAL, LLC.
32026-04-06AO 121 NOTICE by LILY & VAL, LLC
22026-04-06Disclosure Statement identifying NONE as corporate parent or other affiliate by LILY & VAL, LLC. Modified text on 4/6/2026.
12026-04-06COMPLAINT against SCHEDULE A DEFENDANTS (Filing fee, including Administrative fee, $405, receipt number APAWDC-9481417), filed by LILY & VAL, LLC.

免费评估

如您已收到与本案件号相关的 TRO 邮件,可花 30 秒填写评估表,快速获取和解或应诉建议,并初步了解预计处理成本。

立即评估

案件咨询

如你已经收到平台冻结、律师函、TRO 通知或想进一步判断案件影响,可以直接联系我们团队做下一步咨询。

立即咨询
TRO查询 最新资讯 关于我们 联系我们